Talk:Handling trackers: Difference between revisions
From FreeMind
Jump to navigationJump to search
| Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
# ''Con:'' It violates the definition of "pending" used by SourceForge[http://sourceforge.net/docman/display_doc.php?docid=24202&group_id=1#issue_status], according to which "pending" is a synonym to "author action needed", meaning that the author of the item should provide further information so that the team can solve the problem. | # ''Con:'' It violates the definition of "pending" used by SourceForge[http://sourceforge.net/docman/display_doc.php?docid=24202&group_id=1#issue_status], according to which "pending" is a synonym to "author action needed", meaning that the author of the item should provide further information so that the team can solve the problem. | ||
# ''Pro:'' It helps to distinguish issues solved in CVS from those not solved at all. SourceForge does not provide any other suitable state, the other ones being "open", "closed", "deleted". | # ''Pro:'' It helps to distinguish issues solved in CVS from those not solved at all. SourceForge does not provide any other suitable state, the other ones being "open", "closed", "deleted". | ||
# ''Con:'' New users coming to see the trackers | # ''Con:'' New users coming to see the trackers see only open items, not those pending, as I have just verified. Those using the stable version will thus post duplicate entries; presumably many of them will use the stable version. | ||
--[[User:Danielpolansky|Danielpolansky]] 03:16, 14 Jul 2007 (PDT) | --[[User:Danielpolansky|Danielpolansky]] 03:16, 14 Jul 2007 (PDT) | ||
Revision as of 10:27, 14 July 2007
Using "pending" status for issues solved in CVS
Dimitry suggested we could use "pending" status of an item to mark issues solved in CVS. Currently all pending issues are automatically closed after 60 days, but this setting can be changed.
- Con: It violates the definition of "pending" used by SourceForge[1], according to which "pending" is a synonym to "author action needed", meaning that the author of the item should provide further information so that the team can solve the problem.
- Pro: It helps to distinguish issues solved in CVS from those not solved at all. SourceForge does not provide any other suitable state, the other ones being "open", "closed", "deleted".
- Con: New users coming to see the trackers see only open items, not those pending, as I have just verified. Those using the stable version will thus post duplicate entries; presumably many of them will use the stable version.
--Danielpolansky 03:16, 14 Jul 2007 (PDT)
